Methods for measuring toothpaste abrasivity

Abrasivity is an important indicator of a toothpaste. Preventive products without abrasive particles are unable to prevent the formation of bacterial plaque on teeth.1 Products with a higher level of abrasivity have enhanced cleaning properties, but are also a risk factor for the development of non-carious dental lesions.2,3 Therefore, the choice of toothpaste abrasivity level depends on age, the condition of the hard dental tissues, and concomitant diseases.

Until recently, two main indices were used to quantify toothpaste abrasivity: RDA (Relative Dentin Abrasivity) and REA (Relative Enamel Abrasivity). Knowledge of the RDA value is more important, since dentin is more susceptible to abrasion than enamel.4

Relative Dentin Abrasivity (RDA) is a laboratory index used to assess dentin wear under standardized conditions. There is no universal RDA scale that classifies toothpastes into fixed categories (e.g., low, medium, high, very high). According to the American Dental Association (ADA), any product with an RDA value below 250 is considered safe for daily use. Distinctions between values below 250 lack sufficient clinical evidence and are not standardized.

The most popular method for determining RDA today is the radiometric method.5 This method involves brushing irradiated root dentin with the test dental products and a reference abrasive material under standardized conditions. The irradiated dentin particles released during brushing are measured quantitatively. Based on the results obtained, RDA values for the test dental products are calculated relative to the reference material, which is assigned an arbitrary value of 100.

However, this method has a number of disadvantages, namely: poor reproducibility (the RDA value of the same toothpaste sample in different experimental series can differ by almost 10 units), measurement complexity, and, most importantly, low availability for manufacturer, since the only accredited laboratory is located at Indiana University (USA).

Russian Abrasivity Index (RIA)

A new methodology has been developed at the Institute of Digital Dentistry of the RUDN Medical Institute, which has a number of advantages and can become an excellent alternative to the American RDA measurement method. The effectiveness of the RIA measurement methodology and the substantiation of practical recommendations for patients with various oral conditions have been proven by numerous clinical studies.6

The substrate here is a reference material – feldspathic ceramic with more stable hardness indicators than natural dentin or enamel. This reduces the spread of index values in a series of experiments.

Material samples are placed in a special rotary machine7 and subjected to processing that simulates 1 year of standard tooth brushing, while a slurry of the test toothpaste is continuously fed at a set speed onto the treated surface. The toothbrushes mounted in the rotating holder have medium hardness.

 
The figure shows a setup for determining toothpaste abrasivity:
  1. Brush in the holder.
  2. Ceramic block in an epoxy housing.
  3. Blocks with samples and brushes mounted in the rotary machine.
  4. General view of the setup: on the left – dispenser, on the right – rotary machine in a container.

Then the samples are washed, and their surface is scanned using an optical 3D profilometer. The obtained surface reliefs of the sample before and after testing are superimposed on each other for subsequent processing. Image matching is performed based on the relative position of marks (scratches) located at the edges of the samples. Typical view of the sample surface relief before and after testing:

For each set of three-dimensional data, a surface profile averaged over the image width is built (red line – original sample, green line – sample after testing):

From the difference between the profile values «before» and «after» for each test toothpaste sample, an average abrasive wear depth in micrometers is obtained.

To bring this indicator to a more familiar form and obtain the relative RIA index, a simple linear model was built for two toothpaste samples with known RDA values measured in the USA. To be able to normalize data in the future, reference slurries were prepared from commercially available abrasives, for which abrasive wear was also measured and RIA values were calculated.

Thus, the RIA scale represents a simple linear model correlating with the RDA scale values. Despite the apparent simplicity of the approach, the proposed method is an effective means of quantitatively assessing the abrasive capacity of toothpaste, allowing prediction of the paste's effect on the patient's teeth during prolonged use.

Clinical rationale for the application of the RIA index

As part of a clinical study involving 240 patients, the effect of preventive toothpastes with different RIA values on the hard dental tissues and ceramic restorations was investigated.

Based on the condition of the vestibular surface of the anterior teeth, patients were divided into 5 equal groups. Each group was randomly divided into 2 subgroups. Each subgroup received toothpastes with different RIA values to apply twice a day:

Patient group Group RIA of the toothpaste used
Patients with intact teeth 1.1 100
1.2 40
Patients with wedge-shaped defects 2.1 40
2.2 30
Patients with feldspathic ceramic restorations 3.1 100
3.2 40
Patients with lithium disilicate restorations 4.1 100
4.2 110
Patients with zirconium dioxide restorations 5.1 100
5.2 110

For the assessment of oral hygiene PHP index (Podshadley and Haley, 1968) was used at baseline, after 14 days, 6 months and 12 months. In all study groups, six months after the start of the experiment, a decrease in the hygiene index values relative to baseline was recorded, which indicates the effectiveness of the oral hygiene training provided and the cleaning efficacy of all toothpastes used.

Abrasive wear of the teeth and ceramic restorations was determined in vivo with high-resolution intraoral scanner at baseline and after 12 months of daily toothbrushing. The resulting images were compared with each other in a dental restoration design software.

 

It is known that the physiological wear of enamel ranges from 34 to 42 µm per year. The average depth of enamel wear in patients with natural intact teeth corresponded to 34.29±3.01 µm and 19.46±2.00 µm, respectively, for toothpastes with abrasivity values of 100 and 40.

At the same time, in patients with exposed dentin, abrasive wear was, on average, 10 times higher than enamel wear. In the case of using toothpaste with RIA=30, dentin wear amounted to 326.38±15.67 µm, which corresponds to the range of average annual dentin wear according to global scientific data and in-vitro experiments. However, when using toothpaste with RIA=40, the dentin wear value was 442.79±29.91 µm, which exceeds the permissible average annual dentin wear.

The wear depth of ceramic restorations in patients of groups 3–5 was insignificant (up to 2.5 µm), regardless of the toothpaste used.

Thus, based on the results of clinical monitoring of patients with different oral health statuses, RIA values scale can be interpreted as follows:

RIA Area of toothpaste application
0-30 Care for babies up to 3 years old and sensitive teeth
31-60 Regular care for adults and children from 3 years old
61-110 Regular care and gentle whitening
111-140 Intensive cleansing and whitening
141-200 Intensive whitening

R.O.C.S. toothpastes collection for adults and children of all ages was the first to undergo the RIA research and measurement process.

Download RIA research protocol (in Russian):